As winter approaches and holiday flavors return, Starbucks’ seasonal menu once again becomes a point of excitement—and debate. To put these drinks to the test, five reviewers sampled nine popular winter and holiday beverages, rating them and sharing their honest reactions. From festive favorites to one universally disliked option, here’s how Starbucks’ seasonal lineup held up.
One of the highest-rated drinks of the tasting was the Peppermint Mocha, reviewed by Jojo, who gave it an impressive 9.5 out of 10. The drink delivered exactly what it promised: a strong peppermint flavor balanced with just enough chocolate. Jojo described it as “very holiday,” praising how clearly the peppermint came through without overpowering the drink. For anyone looking for a classic winter flavor that feels festive from the first sip, this drink stood out as a clear success.
Jojo also reviewed the Iced Caramel Brûlé Latte, rating it an 8 out of 10. The drink was described as tasting like a caramel frappuccino in iced latte form, with a strong caramel flavor throughout. While not as overtly seasonal as some of the spicier winter options, it was still a solid and enjoyable choice, especially for caramel lovers.
Gingerbread-themed drinks made multiple appearances in the tasting, with mixed results. Quinn reviewed the Gingerbread Latte, giving it a 6 out of 10. While the gingerbread flavor was unmistakable, it was ultimately described as a mid-tier drink, neither good nor particularly memorable. However, the Iced Gingerbread Chai, reviewed by Lucas, told a very different story. Receiving one of the highest scores of the entire tasting at 9.7 out of 10, the drink was praised for its cinnamon-forward flavor and overall balance. Lucas summed it up simply, saying it tasted really good with “no notes,” making it a standout among the winter offerings.
Peppermint drinks were another major theme. Quinn reviewed the regular Peppermint Hot Chocolate, giving it an 8.5 out of 10, but noted that the peppermint flavor was surprisingly hard to taste. Despite that, it was still enjoyable overall. Nadia’s Peppermint White Hot Chocolate earned a slightly lower 7.5 out of 10. She liked how the chocolate chips melted into the drink and found the peppermint flavor moderate, but noted that over time, it began to taste more like plain milk.
The Peppermint Mocha Frappuccino, reviewed by Lucas, received an 8 out of 10. The drink was described as tasting like chocolate-covered peppermint, though the peppermint was strong enough to feel slightly overpowering. Still, it remained a solid option for fans of bold mint flavors.
Not every drink fared well. Jack reviewed Starbucks’ regular Hot Chocolate and gave it a 5 out of 10. He described it as “mid” and compared it unfavorably to home-made hot chocolate, noting that better powder brands are available for much less money. His verdict was clear: it’s not worth the price when cheaper and better alternatives exist.
By far the lowest-rated drink of the tasting was Nadia’s Iced Eggnog Latte, which created such a stir that the whole group reviewed it, giving it a brutal 0.5 out of 10. It was described as watery, gross, and tasting like coffee with a bad aftertaste. The dislike was so strong that everyone present tried it, and it took nine people before someone was willing to finish the drink rather than waste it.
Overall, Starbucks’ seasonal menu delivered a wide range of experiences. While drinks like the Peppermint Mocha and Iced Gingerbread Chai proved to be crowd-pleasers, others, like the Eggnog Latte, failed to impress entirely. For students looking to treat themselves this winter, choosing wisely from the seasonal menu can make all the difference.
Which Starbucks Holiday Drink From Our Review Would You Choose?
Sorry, there was an error loading this poll.
